Probably worth noting for anyone planning on shucking - NewEgg has the 20 TB Seagate Exos for the same price right now. Sep 11, 2017 · At the moment (and throughout 2017, for that matter), the best value in drive shucking has consistently been the example we used in the previous section: the 8TB Western Digital Easystore external USB 3. unshucked the drive into another case (did a little too much damage to the one this came in), and returned it to walmart for a swap, stateing it was a tampered product. Next step is to shuck and attempt to Raid0 the partitions, since it's a little unusual, and I think it's going to be software only, because Raid usually only accepts drives, so speed might be impacted. 14TB seagate expansion did contain Exos a few months ago. There are usually two screws attaching the USB control board. Subtract the price of the external vs the price of the internal. Feb 18, 2019 · The external drive is a much better $/TB ratio than buying actual Reds. Shucking external drives can be a great way to get amazing performance drives f Lets take a look inside a 14TB Seagate external enclosure to see what we get. don't remember exactly what price point the last sale hit. Then you remove the actual hard drive out from the plastic casing. Model is WDC WD140EDGZ-11B1PA0 14000. 2. 3 v pin. Unplugged the faulty drive and my computer boots fine now. Mar 29, 2018. I did some reading in this subreddit about testing the drive before shucking. If Jun 13, 2022 · 1. Looking for recommendations. They cannot predict that a drive will fail weeks, months, or years later. you always want to buy them on sale if possible. T. I used CrystalDiskInfo on my 8TB EasyBooks prior to shucking them. They are cheap compared to buying the bare WD Red drive which makes them a prime target for shucking. And I doubt that most people shucking drives would shuck these. Western Digital Elements Desktop Hard Drive. MBR only allows 2TB when using 512B logical sectors, but allows the full 3TB when using the 4K logical sectors. In the past, I found CC cleaner to be 80% awesome, 20% virus. For example if the external is $200 and the internal is $250. 5" D10 WD_black Xbox One Game Drive Drives so I made one myself. Seagate is OK, wd make 2. This allows you to install the drive into a computer or NAS, rather than having it externally connected by USB. If everything passes, drive goes into my good pile, if something fails, I contact the seller, to get a partial refund for the drive or a return label to send it back. Jan 20, 2019 · The WD Elements (BB Canada) and WD Easystore (BB USA) are reported to contain white label versions of the WD reds. The current good price for a 10TB WD in an enclosure is around $160. so on sale it would be 250 euros or less. Practically every other week the drive is on sale at Best Buy for ~$170 and contains a Western Digital Red drive. Offering up to 4TB of storage space, this hard drive ensures ample room for storing documents, photos, videos, and more. DONE! Thanks! Plug them in via USB (3 hopefully) and run some preclears on them. Then you save $50 for 30min worth of work. 5 days ago · 03. So it makes a lot of sense to look Sep 21, 2021 · An external hard drive is simply a standard SATA HDD mounted in an enclosure with electronics to allow connecting to a PC, typically via USB. Personally, I run a full test suite. Open Remove Shuck. Employee there was kind enough to offer a replacement, so yay! Nov 10, 2020 · In this video, I show you how to shuck the internal SATA hard drive from a WD External 12 TB Elements in real-time, with the purpose of removing the internal 5 days ago · How to make Time Capsule and networked drives appear for your Mac. 3. I see people have covered seagate and wd pretty well so I'll just add that I've heard that toshiba's external drives are unshuckable as well. Prior to shucking any drive it gets verified by running short and long Smart diagnostics Oct 29, 2004 · Shucking WD 10TB Elements USB Drives. My concern is that WD has implemented a new anti-shucking firmware change that causes the drives to be bricked when they are disconnected from their USB adapter card. 0 hard drive. 5 GB. Apparently mine is a SCSI disk. In our case, “de-casing” the portable hard drive so we can use the internal 2. In terms of hard drives (I'm studying IBM's early computer history to the mid-70s right now), in 1956 the very first hard drive had more than twice as much storage. All my latest shuck drives had an issue intenteded by WD, and its the 3. heck, the same model is often sold as a desktop drive as well. As described above, once you shuck an external drive then you’re left with an HDD that can be used for other purposes, such as in a desktop PC as an internal drive, in a server, and in a network attached storage (NAS) device. No more complicated than buying an external hard drive and taking it apart. Dec 20, 2020 · What the Shuck!? What is shucking? How do you shuck hard drives? What is the best drive to shuck? These, and many questions more are answered in this video!I This guide demonstrates shucking a WD Elements 12TB external hard drive from Western Digital, model WDBWLG0120HBK-NESN, but the procedure can apply to any WD Elements 3. R. I did 8 10TB Easystores 2 years ago for my latest file server. Downloaded the "WD Drive Utilities" and started the "Complete Drive Test. May 17, 2024 · The Best External Hard Drives For Shucking. You can spend more for non-refurb or larger drives, but you should make the choice based on your needs and concerns. Severely dating myself, but it reminds me of the days when people who bought a hole punch so they could use cheaper single sided floppy disks in a dual sided drive. 2 of those make for a nice low power RAID1 drive and takes up the same space . drives used in external cases are just hard drives, just like any other desktop drive. Now before someone starts buying up portable external drives like a madman, I should warn you that: Nov 18, 2023 · No this was the surface test with the drive still in the USB3 enclosure. But if you keep the casing, you might still be able to place the drive back, and send for repair with the warranty. This plug-and-play drive offers high storage capacity at more than 50% off. Used extended test to read all blocks, then zero filled, followed by full format using the /P switch with 8ea iterations. #1. But if you're looking for 18tb drives, Toshiba Enterprise 18TB's are on sale right now for $279. 99 Prime Exclusive Deals - Post from r/DailyRedditDeals. W10 Black. Jan 31, 2021 · Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for Seagate Expansion Desktop 14TB External Hard Drive HDD - USB 3. These will write to each sector and read from it to see if same data is presented. Launch Applications > Utilities > AirPort Utility. 01. [so thats newest and fastest edition, newegg still has Exos x14] EDIT: Seagate has new firmware update SN03. Click Go on the top menu bar from the Desktop. There are never any guarantees, when it comes to shucked drives, but WD makes very few different 18 TB drive models: WD Gold, WD Ultrastar and WD Purple Pro are as far as I know the only models currently available in 18 TB models. Sep 28, 2020 · For those that don’t, these enclosures contain what most people suspect are relabled WD Red drives. Bought 3 months ago, last night heard an awful sound come from my computer. Was curious what people thought to going this route to reduce build costs. Seagate 16TB External HDD on sale for $229. Have had two drives fail SMART and needed to be returned so I'm not taking any chances on any new drives I get. It displays the model number of the enclosed drive on the top. It's a lengthy process but should catch a DOA drive before shucking. 66 votes, 16 comments. I got two 12 TB drives (last week's newEgg sale - i know, let's not talk about newegg's reputation). Seagate Backup Plus 14 TB currently contains Ironwolf Pro HDDs Okay, I did not know that. I use a regular case fan running off USB, works really well. There's a Short Test option that performs a relatively fast self-scan, and an Extended Test that checks the whole hard drive for bad Oct 12, 2022 · Unboxing and how to shuck a Western Digital Easystore 8TB, 10TB, 12TB, 14TB, 16TB external hard drive. Simply opening the drive in CrystalDisk or HDDScan will give you a model number and quick (better yet, Extended) S. The problem is that these drives are not meant to be removed by New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Thankfully I haven't had one die on me yet after shucking, but I never keep the case and wouldn't even bother attempting to pass the drive off non-shucked. 1. Test the external drive before shucking. 0 enclousures. It will also help the disk identity any bad sectors. The two I ordered from Newegg last week were WD180EDGZ inside. I record the wwn numbers and serial of each drive, and a copy of any test notes 8TB wwn-0x5000cca03bac1768 -Failed, 26 -Read errors, non recoverable, drive is unsafe to use. That is what Shucking is. Also, these owners have not reported an issue with having to tape off the 3. 5) ZFS Scrub to check any Read, Write, Checksum errors. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. - [Helium] DC HC 510 has both 8TB and 10TB model, HUH72 10 xxALE60y, 8TB version is binned and locked 10TB If everything passes, drive goes into my good pile, if something fails, I contact the seller, to get a partial refund for the drive or a return label to send it back. Seagate and WD are about the same reliability now (in my experience with about 500 drives as datapoints) I've been shucking since 2009. The hosts always talk about shucking drives from external hard drive enclosures to save money- because for some reason hard drives in these USB enclosures can be cheaper than just buying a hard drive. 5" drives now which will probably be 5400rpm. Jan 26, 2017 · Jan 26, 2017. "New" external drive (refurb), clean SMART info (< 10 power on, < 5 hr run time which might not mean much), good extended SMART test, good verify scan, partial read/butterfly tests were fine, but once I tried running the erase test, nothing but bad blocks from the beginning. From reading both MyBooks or Elements - to go with the cheaper - however, it seems here, the best offer is the W10 Black from price vs TB. So I took a SMART scan from before and after an extended write test. If you wanted an Exos you should have gotten the 16TB version. 00 if you buy two by clicking on the combo deal. There is a lot of information about the WD elements (easystore) and WD myBooks. Recent post however suggest that seagate now offers better drives in their external enclosures. (This was also reiterated in the description. The main tool for the job is a pry tool or flat head screw The sixth line (User Capacity) of the pic lists a capacity of 1. Nov 16, 2021. Toshiba Canvio Basics Portable Hard Drive. However, I read recently that the drives should always be spun up and the The plan is to expand storage using shucked hard drives. But at that price I'm stocking up and buying a SAS controller. This tests the drives to make s Shucking drives usually gets you a big discount. This guide demonstrates shucking a WD Elements 12TB external hard drive from Western Digital, model WDBWLG0120HBK-NESN, but the procedure can apply to any WD Elements 3. 4) Fill Test using F3. It's an adaptation of the methods from the wiki. I've done like 50 of the tiny 2TB 2. com/guide/hard-drive-and-ssd-shucking-master-list-of-whi There's not a whole lot you can do for heat transfer when its stuck in a plastic case. First, check with CrystalDiskInfo to see what the drive thinks of itself. It translated to better but still a bit wonky results in HDTune Pro (still lower speeds than 18TBs form 6 months ago) but not far off and there is a catch and it is a good one but first some screenshots: HD Tune Pro result with OE USB adapter (I am getting ~230mb/sec with 18TBs): WD DeskStar 20TB White Label shucked WD Elements. Shuck them or just leave them be. So for me, I’d use /dev/rdisk4. The disk itself commonly shows a 512B logical sector size. After shucking, I inserted it into a HDD docking station and it worked fine with the file intact. An external drive with a media collection, for example. Always buy from a reputable seller like BestBuy, Amazon, or B&H. Yep, that's the baseline price per TB for cheapest server class drives with 3 year warranty or more. 3v reset, the drives wont work on most sata power connectos due to this issue, for me required to use molex to sata power to make them work my server so just be warned if you dont see the drive being recognized test this before. Stick all your drives together get crafty with some cardboard to make a funnel and put a 120mm fan on top. There is a little more work involved once you In this video I go through the simple steps to remove an 18TB WD SATA drive from its USB Enclosure. Award. Step 2: Remember different devices have different way of removing the enclosure to extract the physical Hard Drive. 5" that don't have sata but only usb. I was very confused, in part, because I very recently retired a 1 TB drive and thought I had picked it up by accident, but the date didn't seem quite right. By punching a hole in the case, they could fool the drive. Going to convert to a Raid 6 once the 4 drives finish preclearing. Just got my first 10TB HDD and I thought it would be a good idea to test it before I shuck. ) Confirm the drive is seen in Disk Utility. The Seagate 18tb Expansion (STKP18000400) has become available at a lower price than the 14-16TB external drive. Mar 28, 2020 · To shuck a drive means to disassemble an external hard drive and separate the actual hard drive from its enclosure. The sixth line under the Attributes Section (Power_On_Hours) shows 7175 hours of use. Looks like all new external WD drives have the controller board soldered onto the HD itself, and it is a USB connection, and there is no SATA port at all. Backup disks are then shucked as needed and used for pool replacement disks. In the Properties window, navigate to the “Tools” tab. I've got green lights for everything before and after the test except temperature after because my dumbass didn't take the plastic covering off the HDD before I ran the test. You should always run a diagnostic check before shucking your drives though. Got new drive, came home, plugged it in without shucking, and got the old WD dead syndrome, drive spins up (vibrated badly) makes a few clicking sounds and spins down. On Windows, I do a DoD wipe (HDTune or whatever) followed by a surface scan (StableBit Scanner). I received my WD Easystores today, looking for some experienced folk to sanity check my test plan before shucking them. Anyone know if these have an EXOS drive? Plan to use it as is and eventually shuck it. I ended up buying 11 of them for home and work. Now divide that by the amount of time you believe it will take you to shuck the drive. Featuring ample storage capacity and reliable performance, the Western Digital Elements Desktop Hard Drive is a solid choice for storing all your important files and data. That said, secure wipe to stress a drive is a great idea, and I do like the CC cleaner suggestion. Crystal disk info looked spotless. Possibly your boot drive. Seagate Backup Plus 5TB's are shuckable. # of posts, like age, doesn't translate to knowledge. Apr 5, 2023 · Hard Drive and SSD Shucking, Master List of Which Drives Are Inside USB Drives - https://nascompares. Nov 23, 2023 · Get a WD 16TB External HDD for $210. Check disk utility to see what /dev device to use. Is there a program to run to do this? I'm currently on Win10, will probably switch to ProxMox before the end of the year. Well 3tb aren't the most common, and under 4tb you're most likely to find 2. 16TB for $223. 0TB. 1. 8Ghz), 512 MB of RAM, FreeNAS 9. my "test" is verifying they are the size I purchased, and copying my current backup set to them. The circuit on the back is connected to nothing lol. If you've reached your limit on desktop data storage at home, or suspect that you Jan 23, 2024 · Hard drives can be expensive, especially if you are using a LOT of storage for all of your devices and services. not guarantied, the only one that so far always had Exos was the 16TB one. Platter hard drives are fragile things and stores don't package them properly most of the time when they ship them. The first with a removable disk pack in 1961 had 2MiB. Sep 20, 2018 · How Drive Shucking Works, and What You Get. And even if there wasn’t a sale, the 14TB WD Easystore regularly sells for $260 —still a healthy markdown. 0 for PC Laptop - 1-Year Rescue Service (STEB14000402) , Black at Amazon. Step 1: Research the device’s serial number to make sure it can be shucked. I do not own any external HDs (though I use internal drives in external USB 3. 5" Seagates. This is the external drive that has the Ultrastar DC HC520 12TB Data Center Drive inside. 5" drive inside because it's cheaper to buy the external drive than it is to just buy the internal drive itself. It's a plugin you can install on your unraid NAS. The warranty of external drives usually differ from their Dec 22, 2020 · Shucking is the process of taking an external hard drive (like a USB drive that you attach to your computer with a cable) and taking it apart. SMR like most Seagates but review suggest they still perform reasonably. Hard Drive Shucking (and in recent years, even SSD shucking) is the process of purchasing an external HDD/SSD enclosure, such as WD My Book or Seagate Backup Plus drive, and then cracking open the casing to get the drive inside. To buy the bare drive is north of $400. Only use PMR drives. " Before that I set the Windows 10 "turn off hard drives after" to never. Model - WDBWLG0120HBK-NESN. Right-click on the drive and select “Properties” from the context menu. Waaa overkill. Just a full format (not quick) is likely all you really need. In this context, it's buying an external hard drive and "shucking" the case off of it to get to the 3. I was picking them up for $200 in December. Also get an ssd as a boot drive. I have the results from I've been shucking for a few years now and gone through 15+ drives over multiple years and I always do a full write/read test and then check smart stats before shucking. Afterwards a short SMART test, surface check, h2testw run, and at the end, I check the SMART report again to see if something besides the power-on hours has changed. For the Canadian Elements drive, many owners have reported that the drives are white label, helium-filled, 256 MB cache, 5400 rpm, and TLER enabled. i have HDDScan currently running a 'butterfly' scan, but wanted to ask for preferred testing methods. What a relief to know actually lol. 2. Once done, check your SMART stats. Use a screwdriver to remove these and slide the board off the SATA port of the hard drive. A. That feature wasn't available last time I used it. This is important in order to avoid any surprises after you’ve disassembled the outer shell. Fun tip: external drives have logic in the SATA->USB board to ensure a 4K logical sector size is exposed to the operating system. For me the first USB disk is always /dev/disk4. f3write /TESTR001 && f3read /TESTR001. (Image Compare that to a recent sale of a 14TB external drive from the same manufacturer, down to a historically low $190. After removing the drive and cleaning up enclosure parts, I saw a 1 TB Toshiba drive dated July 2013. Use /dev/rdisk# for badblocks to give it exclusive access to the device. Select your Time Capsule and click Edit. This was the first and only drive I ever actually tested before shucking - go figure. I'd rather pay less and do extensive testing on the drives before use. Original: Dell Optiplex 170L (Pentium 4 511 - 2. M. I thought that was it but then a day later when I tried to access the drive, Windows 10 indicated that I needed to format the drive. I always test before shucking. That pretty much means there is no good way to recover data if the USB controller fails, they are basically throw well non-NAS drives aren't technically made to go in a NAS, but that's true regardless of whether or not they were shucked. So, my thinking is that it's a good idea to test the drives once they arrive in order to make sure that they didn't arrive defective (with bad blocks). Just couple days ago, before I shucked an 8 TB easystore drive, I copied a file to test if it'll retain data. Smr are fine in non-raid settings where data is written rarely and read more often. It's best practice to do a preclear on your hard drives in Unraid before you take them out of the plastic shell (shuck them). ) The external Seagate drive should appear in this list as a selectable drive. They are really bad at repeated writing or extended writing, and can screw raid rebuild times. current price for WD external drives 14 TB is roughly 270 euros, but that is because they are NOT on sale rightnow. I say take the best deal you get and backup the data just in case. Like shucking corn. If it isn't, check that box and then click Update, which restarts the base station. Shucking a drive means to remove the hard drive from its enclosure. Yay! Edit: less blurry picture Edit 2: Bought them from Bestbuy. unless you physically damaged the drives while shucking them, they won't be any more likely to fail on you. Shucking can void warranty. It takes a while but it greatly reduces the risk of getting drive that will fail soon. Jun 4, 2024 · Western Digital Dashboard is free hard drive testing software for Windows that lets you run several hard drive tests. If you're using Windows get the drive vendors own software and run a long read write test. It supports viewing Self-Monitoring, Analysis, and Reporting Technology (SMART) information. Don’t screw up the disk number or it will wipe a drive with data on it. So Apr 16, 2023 · As long as there have been ready-made USB external hard drives, there has been shucking. That’s a cool $160 savings over the standalone bare drive, nearly a 50% discount. Step by step shucking Hard Drive guide 2022. - [AIr] DC HC330 has only 10TB, most common model: WUS721010ALE6L4. ) OP stated they ordered a brand new 12TB EasyStore, which is an external hard drive made by Western Digital, not their major competitor Seagate. I had this exact same problem. I have been doing some research and found varying results for what the best external HDD is for shucking. And you think it will take you 30min to shuck the drive. WDBA5E0120HBK-EESN – 12TB – 250€ edit - 347€ cheapest in stock at the moment. Shucking an external hard drive can be a gre May 2, 2020 · I couldn't find a video on how to shuck the 3. Some people shuck them beforehand, replace with older drives, and return for reselling. When you get into the high capacity drives (8/10TB) it's cheaper to buy the external drive and shuck than the equivalent internal drive. 3v mod. Shucking, as the practice has come to be known, is the process of buying an external drive, opening it up, and removing the bare drive for use within a PC. Will put me at 7x8TB and 1x2TB with 42TB of space. Nov 25, 2021 · Might be better to buy a newer model single bay enclosure from Synology/QNAP or a home built NAS box to put the 18TB drive into if one doesn’t use it as an USB external hard drive to an existing NAS box or computer. Shucking a drive is the act of removing the drive from it’s enclosure. I usually have like 8 of them running at once. Yes, I run them through a read/write test with HD Sentinel on Windows. Choose Utilities. 7 (x86), no ZFS, and it ran fine. The main reason people shuck drives is financial because external drives tend to be cheaper than internal drives. Whats inside is standard Green/White/Black label Seagate Exos x16 - ST14000NM001G, Firmware SN02. Computer was unresponsive, shut down, and would no longer post (with hard drive screeching). My suggestion would be to wire it back to the If everything passes, drive goes into my good pile, if something fails, I contact the seller, to get a partial refund for the drive or a return label to send it back. WD Data Center Drive Summary: the last letters L4 means No Power Disable Pin, thus no need for 3. In the Disks tab, make sure Enable File Sharing is checked. Remove the USB control board. Oct 20, 2023 · Follow these steps to scan your external hard drive for errors: Open the file explorer on your computer and locate the external hard drive. 5" stat drive with a usb interface. Or use badblocks in Linux. With its sleek design and compact size, the Toshiba Canvio Basics Portable Hard Drive is a reliable storage solution for on-the-go users. I run Windows machines right now (the drives will be in an Unraid system once I figure that out) I have access an HDD Sentinel Pro license and as such would want to do all tests WD180EDGZ Elements Newegg. It seems crazy, but sometimes, buying an external drive can actually be cheaper than buying a similar internal drive with the same specs. Feb 28, 2020 · 4. Seagate is also doing this from what I have been seeing. SAS though, not SATA. WD 20TB external also on sale for $320 but the Seagate is a much better value $/TB and I already have an EXOS drive so I'd rather have a matching HDDs later. Use CrystalDiskInfo to get the model number of the drive, and get S. zpool scrub TESTR001. My first time shucking an external HDD too. 5” external drive. Currently running 3x8TB and 1x2TB drives in a Raid 5. com. 5″ drive as a standard hard drive. Thanks! One full preclear should be enough but for drives I’m going to use as Parity, I do 3x preclears. Aug 19, 2008 · I think that's the stress you're looking for. Is it 7200rpm regular SMR drive? no sane person would shuck an SMR drive. Nov 25, 2017 · In this video, I show you how to shuck the internal SATA HDD from an external Seagate Backup Plus Hub drive (not to be confused with a regular Backup Plus). ) My reason is it seems the price per GB is lower on external drives versus internal drives, while often having regular internal drives in an enclosure. I guess I was kinda excited and just started shucking without plugging it in first. Edit: or $274. Note: Before shucking, be sure to boot up the external drive and run a deepscan for bad sectors using a program like HD Tune Pro or Stablebit Scanner. Before going further, since “shucking” isn’t an overly popular term, it essentially means “de-shelling”. Buy external drives for shucking from reputable sources. - [Air] DC HC320 has only 8TB, most common model: HUS728T8TALE6L4. Most if not all external USB (desktop not portable) drives are just a 3. I run some benchmarks, Segate advertises Exos x16 as 262MB/s HDD, well in 1. I was going to shuck this drive, then I wanted to do the bad sector test before I do. WDBWLG0140HBK-EESN – 14TB – 360€. Jun 15, 2020 · 4,840. Some will see it as almost criminal to put such a large hard drive into such an old (and crippled) NAS box. ) Once Disk Utility is launched a drive list will be displayed in the left hand column. data that will tell you if the drive is new and free of errors. i think you Just shucked Seagate Expansion Desktop 14TB HDD from Amazon. The Seagate Expansion 10TB drives are Barracuda Compute Pro - 7200RPM PMR drives. T data to see if the drive is new and free of errors Try copying some files over and see if it works as expected Run a surface test using Hard Disk Sentinel (is the free version is enough for a beginner?) Sep 14, 2020 · Shucking a Seagate Expansion 10TB external hard drive to reveal a Seagate Barracuda Pro disk inside for 2/3 of the price. Late reply but since this thread comes up in google, I thought I'd chime in. Choose Disk Utility. With storage options ranging from 1TB to 18TB, this hard drive provides Whoever replaced the hard drive took off the PCB on the back too. jd tf zi jv nl ja lm xq lo yu